Sunday, September 7, 2008

It Takes One To Tango: Part 2

Hopefully in my last I opened up your mind to consider that it may only take you to change your marriage for the better. Some may argue that the following techniques are a form of manipulation. Like I do, Weiner believes that manipulation gets a bad rap - we are all manipulators. Manipulation simply means we are attempting to influence someone else's behavior toward our own ends. Everyone does this! When our motivation is good and our technique is loving, there is nothing to be ashamed of here. Our actions towards others always result in some sort of reaction - thus the wiser and more noble the attempts to influence them the better. We need to plan and think carefully about our actions so as to preserve and protect our most important relationships. Those who think they are not trying to manipulate their loved ones are believing a deception. Of course there is bad manipulation (with bad motives, not respecting people's autonomy) and good motivation (good motives, with respect to people's right to choose their destiny). Here are few ways that one person can effect radical change on a relationship:

1. Cheerleading. Ask yourself this question: are you more complimentary or critical? Most people will say they are more critical. Often our greatest criticism is reserved for those closest to us. Research shows that the single most effective way to modify someones behavior is to positively reward that person when they behave in way that you want them to. Simple. In marriage we often lose sight of the fact that our spouse does many things we like - and we take it for granted. Punishment and criticism rarely work to change someone (although we get stuck trying it again and again). Many marriages have been saved by one partner choosing to thank and compliment their partner for the things that they appreciate - instead of focusing and criticizing them for everything they do wrong. Sometimes all a relationship needs to get it back on track is one partner sincerely complimenting and honoring something the other partner has done. The partner feels appreciated and reciprocates - it works.

2. Focus on the problem free times. Most couples who come into therapy are deep in the midst of big problems. They've fought, argued, and feel hopeless that thing will change. One way to find a solution to current problems is focus on the problem free times. "When are things better?" "When was a time that you weren't fighting?" "What was different then?" Many couples will say that they were weren't fighting when the wife wasn't nagging, the husband listened to her, when they spent regular time together, etc. Many, many times the answer on how to fix things is simply to return to what you did when times were better. What's changed? What was different then? Can you start doing those things again?

3. Act as if. There is a famous story in counseling. A woman came in saying that she hated her ignorant husband and wanted to get a divorce. The counselor asked her if she really wanted to "get him good" beforehand. She was intrigued. He told her that to really get him back for all the terrible things he'd done to her she should spend the next six months acting as if she truly loved him. Then when she surprised him with the divorce he'd be destroyed. The woman agreed: she would do everything in her power to act like she loved and adored her husband and then in six months - wham! The counselor encouraged her but told her it would only work if she would devote herself completely to the ruse. Six months later the woman came back in. The counselor asked if she wanted a divorce. She was shocked. Divorce him? Never! As she began to pretend that she loved him, her feelings towards him started to reflect her actions. Not only that, but her husband noticed the change and began to act more lovingly towards her as well! Sometimes as well when we approach our spouse we have a negative assumption about how things will turn out. Fight this assumption, instead act as if it will go very well. Our attitudes and assumptions change our interactions. Try it.

4. Do something different. It is fascinating how humans will keep on doing the same thing in a relationship even though it never works. This could include shouting, criticizing, withdrawing, ignoring, nagging, pursuing, etc. Cathy was someone who every time her husband was upset, assumed he was angry or upset with her. She would frequently ask "What's wrong?" He would respond with "Nothing." She'd then say "I know something is wrong, what is it?" He would say, "Nothing, please stop asking me that." She would insist that her perception was right and eventually he would explode in anger. One day she decided to do something different. In the car she noticed her husband was sullen. "What's wrong?" she asked. "Nothing," he responded. Instead of pursuing him she tried something new by turning on the radio and singing to a song. Within a few minutes he said "Hon, do you mind if I turn down the radio, there's something I'd like to discuss with you." He proceeded to share his feelings about something that happened that day. It was the first time in their entire marriage that he opened up to her voluntarily. She changed, he changed! Another story. A man who wanted to change things told his wife that from now on if they were going to fight, they were going to do so without their clothes on. Since this would obviously eliminate a lot of public place for fighting in, they agreed to it. Inevitably one day they started to argue and the man began angrily shedding his clothes. His wife couldn't believe he was serious and started laughing. Soon they were both laughing! By changing their behavior the couple managed to change the way they interacted. Arguments became less common and were over faster. Couples get into behavior cycles together. When one person chooses to do something different they choose to break that cycle. Breaking the cycle is the first step to better solutions and better marriages. . .

These techniques are not guaranteed to solve the big, difficult issues in a marriage. Instead they are useful in helping two people get to a place where they are not captive to old ways of doing their relationship that just won't work. Tomorrow I'll share two last techniques that are slightly more controversial . . . and powerful.

May Light increase!

8 comments:

Jay Boaz said...

I find your third point interesting; more exactly, I find the story interesting. Wasn't that kind of a "hail mary" play? It may have ended up working in this case, but what if it hadn't? It seems that either a home run was going to be hit or the World Series would be over, y'know, with no inbetween. My initial, uninformed impression is that was inappropriate counseling advice. What's your take on it Mark?

Jay

Mark said...

It's only inappropriate if it doesn't work! OK, no seriously, excellent question. Often when clients come in and they are planning to divorce their husband, you have very few possibilities on where to go. My guess is here that the counselor viewed it as a "one shot" possible to stave off divorce and that was to give her a homework assignment to delay her decision (a lot can happen in 6 months) and try to make a behavioral change. Since one person's behavior almost always will result in behavior changes in the other person, it was a gamble but an educated one. Was it unethical? My guess is certain therapist would say yes and others say no. Desperate times call for desperate measures? I think it all depends on the wife's motivation to divorce immediately. It's its high, then the counselor's approach can be justified. If the motivation was low, then it is not justified and puts the client and her marriage at risk. What if it didn't work? Well if she was convinced to divorce him, there was little the counselor could do to convince her to give him another chance anyway - why not try something radical? The key to this working is that the woman must make sure her "acting" is thorough. The counselor gets her to stop doing the unloving she that was doing and only do loving things towards him. If this doesn't happen, it won't work. Would I do this? Only if I was down to almost nothing for options. But it does show the power of "acting as if" quite well, doesn't it?

Jay Boaz said...

It just seems to me a counselor saying "Hey, wanna screw with your husband?" is unprofessional and unethical. The counselor has an ulterior motive to this and as such is being dishonest with the client. If I went to to therapy and was "tricked" in such a manner I don't think I'd be very happy with the therapist. If you went to a doctor who prescribed a medication that turned out to be a placebo, wouldn't you be upset?

Jay

Stacey said...

I find it hard to believe that anyone goes to counseling to simply "announce" they are divorcing. They may say they are ready to divorce because they are at their wit's end, they are under highly emotional circumstances and they are making the step to receive counseling to save their marriage. Maybe one party "shows up" to appease their spouse. Or to say that when it's over to themselves that they at least showed up. I don't know. Sounds like this counselor needs a little counseling himself. He may have posed a "what if" scenerio to the client but his approach seems wrong to me. Then again I'm amazed if this story is true that the woman took him seriously. I think I would have high-tailed out of that office!

Mark said...

Jay: Would I be upset if a doctor used a placebo on me. Maybe . . . but probably not. It all depends on how desperate I was for it to work! I hear what you are saying though, it does have sense of unethicalness to it all. Therapists trick people all the time (as do doctors actually, you'd be surprised at how many of them offer unnecessary tests or placebo like treatments to their patients. Of course that doesn't make it right necessarily . . .

Stacey: Lots of people actually go to counseling fully intending to divorce (with or without their partner). You'd think it's counter-intuitive but a lot of people decide to divorce and have a lot of pain (and they want to work through that pain and other logistical issues with someone). Divorce in their mind is assumed. I like to think there is still hope but some clients would be quite upset for you to suggest ways for them to work things out. If they react badly to that suggestion you could lose them as a client. Of course we have no idea how the female client in the story was presenting but it was certainly a risk (although there are few really negative side affects while the "experiment" goes on). Would I do it? No, I don't think so. But it is a good illustration of the principle of "as if" I think.

Stacey said...

I'm not saying there are those who say they feel that way. And I'm not the professional here. I'm just saying I find it hard to believe. One may come to their counselor and express their desire to divorce, that they see no other option. Hey I've been there... if I'm sitting in a counselor's office because the next step is divorce, well, we all say that at one point. I just think it's then the counselor's obligation to carefully assess their client and help them uncover what lies beneath. If you can't get thru to a couple during this time it is then that the counselor should suggest individual sessions. They should help the client understand that if they think a difficult marriage is painful, divorce is moreso. And that the road to recovery from a divorce is a long process that will take a lot of work. Do they want to go through that and say to themselves "what if" I tried this or that? Ask the client if they entered the marriage with a lot of thought and if they gave a lot of effort while they were in the marriage. (I'm assuming most people will say yes) Then tell them to not enter a divorce without that same effort. Having personally gone through it I can say I tried a lot of different scenerios. In the end all roads lead to divorce. But I still see a lot of people giving up way too soon. I have also "counseled" a few friends about to divorce and this is always my advice to them. And to seek a professional. In some cases, it worked out. I agree in the 'as if' principle, and it is a good one. I was just put off by the counselor in your story who suggested the 'get him good' technique. And I still maintain I would have run for the hills!

Stacey said...

P.S. I meant to add that it is difficult I'm sure when someone comes and says they are ready to divorce. There are not a lot of options because you can't ask someone 'how much longer can you hang in there with things status quo'? Because they are done. They are tired and finished. People think they don't have the energy to wait for the spouse to make all the changes so that they can finally be happy. When you're miserable with someone it's hard to look at yourself in the situation. Especially if the spouse will not participate in counseling. Where do you go as a counselor? Enter the 'as if' scenerio. It seems so absurd and simple and in many cases it works beautifully because it's about breaking the old habits that couples get stuck in. But it's all dependent on what the issues are. This principle doesn't really address serious issues.

OK that's the end of my "book" on this topic. I always find these counseling posts interesting! :) And as you know I have so much to say! haha

Thanks Mark!

Unknown said...

Hi,
My name is Sharon Vergis and I am the assistant editor of counselor.org. I am contacting you today in hopes of developing a relationship with your website; we have seen your site and think your content is great. Counselor.org is a purely informational site dedicated to the general Public.

I hope you show some interest in building relationship, please contact me at sharon.counselor.org@gmail.com.